Baseball Trivia Quiz Member Articles

friday, september 03, 2010
1,277 current members
weekly trivia since march 2000

home	join btq	current btq	last week's btq	btq archive	btq big shooters	online btq
articles	forums	on this date	quotes	ask us a q	weekly notes	contact us

Ray Chapman and Carl Mays
by: Michael Costanzo submitted: 03-03-2006

Throughout the course of major league baseball history, there have been millions upon millions of pitches thrown. Only one of these pitches has killed a man. This man was Cleveland Indians shortstop Ray Chapman. The pitcher was New York Yankees right-hander Carl Mays. The date of the unfortunate incident was August 16, 1920, right in the middle of a heated pennant race. A seemingly popular myth that still exists today is that the spitball was banned because of the Ray Chapman killing. That is false, as the spitball was banned in February of 1920, with the exception of two pitchers per team being allowed to continue throwing the pitch until it was eventually phased out.

Although connected by this baseball tragedy, Chapman and Mays were thought of about as differently as two players could be in the game. Mays, even before the incident, was one of the most disliked players in the league, despite being one of the games very best pitchers. Players complained for years that Mays would deliberately throw at them. His submarine like motion made seeing the ball almost impossible for a right handed hitter. In 1919, at a game in Philadelphia, against the A?s, May?s temper got the best of him. Fans pounded on top of the dugout so hard that he came out and pegged a ball into the stands, injuring two people.

Ray Chapman on the other hand, was extremely well liked by almost everyone in the game. He was always known to be smiling or laughing. He would often sing to his Indians teammates and was thought to be such a talent in that area that he considered a career in singing after baseball. A sad fact in Chapman?s death is that he had promised his wife that he would seriously consider retirement after the 1920 season was over. She thought the sport was too dangerous.

On the afternoon of August 16, Ray Chapman took his usual position in the batting order of second. The first pitch of the 5th inning to Chapman struck him in the left temple, sending him to the ground and sending the ball back to Mays. Thinking the ball hit Chapman?s bat, Mays threw the ball to first base for what he thought was an out. Chapman eventually tried to walk off on his own, but collapsed and was aided. Unfortunately, his skull was so badly damaged that surgery could not save his life in the end.

After the incident, Mays received death threats from angry fans. He partially put blame on umpire Tom Connolly for not putting the thrown ball out of play, since it was getting difficult to see. Many players around the league wanted Mays thrown out of baseball altogether. Teams even considered boycotting games in which he pitched, but nothing ever came of that. In fact, in his first start after the Indians game, Mays through a complete game shutout against the Tigers.

As for the Indians, Harry Lunte replaced Ray Chapman in the lineup. But soon he injured himself and Cleveland turned to unproven youngster Joe Sewell out of desperation. All Sewell did was hit .329 for the month of September in the middle of one of the most exciting pennant races to date in the American League.

With the memory of Ray Chapman still prevalent and his replacement Sewell playing great, the Indians found themselves in the World Series against the Brooklyn Dodgers. Game 5 was one of the most memorable in series history as Elmer Smith of the Indians hit the first ever World Series grand slam and Cleveland 2nd baseman Bill Wambsganss turned the first and only unassisted triple play in series history. Cleveland completed one of the most emotionally taxing seasons in history by beating the Dodgers 5 games to 2 and becoming World Series champions.

Other MISC Articles

Ray and Carl		03-04-2006 09:15
Ray Chapman & Carl Mays		03-03-2006 13:23

To reduce spam posts, you are required to log in to make a comment.

Don't have an account, create one!

Theme: none
Date: Aug 24, 2003

Scott Podsednik stole home yesterday for the Milwaukee Brewers, the first by a Brewer since this player did it July 28, 1998.

show answer

see all baseball trivia...

"I think being able to play the infield, especially shortstop, is something you are born with. You can't learn it."

by Dave Concepcion

more quotes...

'17 - Philadelphia's Grover Cleveland Alexander went the distance in both games of the Phillies' 5-0 and 9-3 sweep of the Brooklyn Dodgers.
'57 - Warren Spahn of the Milwaukee Braves recorded his 41st career shutout with an 8-0 victory over the Cubs at Wrigley Field. Spahn's shoutout set a major league record for lefthanded pitchers.
'70 - Billy Williams of the Cubs asked to be kept out of the lineup, snapping his National League record of 1,117 consecutive games played. His record was broken in 1983 by Steve Garvey.
'81 - The Boston Red Sox and the Seattle Mariners played the longest game in Fenway Park's history, 19 innings, before the game was suspended with the score tied 7-7. The Mariners won 8-7 in 20 innings when the game resumed the next day.
'86 - Billy Hatcher's homer in the top of the 18th inning gave the Houston Astros an 8-7 victory over the Chicago Cubs. The two teams played 14 innings the day before and used a major league record 53 players in the game.
'90 - Bobby Thigpen set a major league record with his 47th save in a 4-2 Chicago White Sox victory over Kansas City. Thigpen broke the record set by Dave Righetti of the New York Yankees in 1986.

more dates...

For the 1949 season, Joe DiMaggio became the first player to earn $100,000 for a season. He was originally looking at a contract that called for $90,000 plus attendance incentives. Toots Shor, a friend and saloonkeeper, advises him to ask for the $100,000 flat salary instead.